Breaking
December 25, 2024

Why Zone 3 Cardio Is Just as Good as Zone 2 Beth Skwarecki | usagoldmines.com

There are benefits to training in heart rate zone 2, and you’ve probably heard all about them. But what happens when your heart rate spikes into zone 3, whether when you’re on a run or doing cardio at the gym? Surprise—you don’t lose the benefits of zone 2 training. Zone 3 is arguably just as good for you, or maybe even better.

Remember, the reason people are excited about zone 2 training is that it helps you build your aerobic base and burn calories without incurring much fatigue. Guess what zone 3 training also does? Yep, it helps you build your aerobic base, burn even more calories, and usually only incur a tiny bit more fatigue than zone 2. So why aren’t we all doing more zone 3 cardio?

Zone 2 is overrated

There are reasons to run (or do any cardio) at lower intensities, and reasons to use higher intensities. Before heart rate monitors were widespread, you had to judge what was “easy” by yourself, or by comparing your speed of running to what you knew you could do in a race. Non-athletes had the “talk test”: If you could hold a conversation while jogging, you knew you were at an easy, steady pace. 

But when everybody has a watch that tells them their heart rate, suddenly we’re looking at specific numbers, and our watches color code the numbers so you know when you’re in zone 2 versus zone 3. Your heart ticks up a beat? You’re out of your zone. Straight to workout jail!

But the reality is, your body isn’t getting a drastically different workout at 153 beats per minute than it was at 152. There probably isn’t even much difference between, say, 145 and 155, as long as they’re both within that conversational-ish effort level.

Workout zones aren’t real

The most popular heart rate zone systems are made up, with no precise relationship to what’s going on in your body. Your body does have some dividing lines when it comes to exercise intensity (like the point at which you can’t speak comfortably anymore, or the point at which lactate accumulates faster than you can clear it), but these don’t correspond exactly to the typical five-zone system.

The five-zone system, as a refresher, is based on where your heart rate falls as a percentage of your maximum heart rate. There will be specific percentages defined as the boundaries of each zone, and the five zones are usually described something like this:

  • zone 1: rest or minimal effort

  • zone 2: easy breezy conversational pace

  • zone 3: ???

  • zone 4: pretty hard

  • zone 5: maximal effort

It’s a cute idea, and many people find this system helpful, but these zones are not based on any scientific findings that prove we get such-and-such benefits at 60-70% of max heart rate, and such-and-such different benefits at 71-80%. If you aren’t convinced, just look at how different gadgets and apps define the zones differently: Your “zone 2” might be 60-70% on Apple Watch, but 65%-75% on a Peloton.  

Research on the benefits of exercise doesn’t use heart rate zones, or at least not of this type. They may measure intensity in a few different ways, including whether you are above or below your ventilatory threshold (basically, whether or not you can talk while exercising) or your lactate threshold (measured through blood chemistry, but basically the highest effort you can sustain for a long time). Sometimes they’ll measure METs, which relate to how much energy you use to do work, or they’ll put everything in terms of oxygen consumption (this is where the term VO2max comes from). Occasionally these studies will send participants home with heart rate-based guidelines, but those tend to be drawn from their personal scientific measurements, rather than the cookie-cutter zones you get from an app or from watching a video on youtube.

Conversational pace includes zone 2 and most of zone 3

So let’s take a closer look at that idea of the “talk test” or “conversational pace.” The guideline to keep your easy cardio at a chatty pace does come from a scientific concept: the ventilatory threshold. 

Imagine you start out at a walk, and every minute or so you increase your speed a bit. As you work harder, you’ll hit a point where your breath becomes a little ragged, and your sentences choppy. If you were conversing with a friend, you’d be grunting out a few words at a time, rather than casually telling a story. That point is your ventilatory threshold, or VT (sometimes called VT1). 

When athletes or coaches talk about easy pace or easy efforts, they usually want you below your VT. The way people talk about zone 2, you’d think that the VT occurs at the top of zone 2. But nope—conversational pace is closer to 80%, which is the top of zone 3. For example, here’s a study on recreational runners that found VT1 to be, on average, at 78% of the runners’ max heart rate. And they tested the runners’ max heart rate, rather than using a formula based on age. (Never trust the default formulas.) 

So if you’re trying to train at an easy pace, or if you’re using the 80/20 rule to keep 80% of your runs easy, you can do those easy runs or cardio sessions in zones 2 and 3, not just zone 3. 

Zone 3 is still aerobic and still easy

Now that I’ve explained why the zone 2/zone 3 distinction is arbitrary, you see why it makes more sense to look at zones 2 and 3 (or even zones 1 through 3) as a continuum. At the lower end, you’ll be running or pedaling slower, burning fewer calories, and feeling like you’re barely doing any work. (Hello, cozy cardio!) 

At the higher end (or the top of zone 3), you’re still getting a lot of aerobic work done, still benefiting your mitochondria and your capillaries and everything else, but you’re doing it in less time. If you’re interested in calorie burn per hour, zone 3 is more efficient. 

Cyclists sometimes call training in this range the “sweet spot.” It gives you some of the advantages of harder training without making you too fatigued. For runners, zone 3 may include some of your tempo runs, some of your race-pace runs, and some of your faster “easy” runs. 

So what’s the point of zone 2, if you can get all of its benefits in zone 3? That depends on your big picture: If you’re doing a lot of training, you’ll probably want some of it to be in zone 2, if only to save some energy while you’re getting more miles on your feet. But if you only run, say, three times a week, it’s unlikely that those couple of runs will wear you down much even if you do them all in zone 3. 

You shouldn’t read too much into your heart rate anyway

This brings me back to my grudge against heart rate monitors. (It’s a grudge borne of love; I track my own heart rate when I run and find it useful in many ways.) 

Your heart rate doesn’t only track with your training effort; it also responds to a lot of other factors. For example, it responds to summer heat, showing you higher numbers in hot weather. It can also show higher numbers if you’re more fatigued, or at the end of a run compared to the beginning, and it may show higher numbers if you’re a bit dehydrated. When you run a race, you may find that your heart rate is higher than expected at the start, just because you’re a bit nervous. Some medications can alter your heart rate as well—beta-blockers, for example, notoriously lower your heart rate.

And then there’s the question of whether your fitness tracker’s zones are set correctly (even knowing that, yes, their boundaries are made up). If you’ve never run an all-out race or series of hill sprints, your watch may have never seen your maximum heart rate. So if it says that your max must be 184 because you are 36 years old, it’s just grabbing numbers from a formula. That makes as much sense as buying shoes based on the average shoe size for a 5’6” woman, rather than actually measuring your feet (or trying on the shoes). If you go out for an easy run and find that your heart rate was in “zone 5” the whole time, I guarantee you that isn’t your zone 5. 

So if your heart rate creeps into zone 3 on a “zone 2” training run, that may or may not be accurate. But even if it is, if you can still breathe and speak more-or-less normally, you’re getting plenty of benefits from your zone 3 cardio. 

 

This articles is written by : Nermeen Nabil Khear Abdelmalak

All rights reserved to : USAGOLDMIES . www.usagoldmines.com

You can Enjoy surfing our website categories and read more content in many fields you may like .

Why USAGoldMines ?

USAGoldMines is a comprehensive website offering the latest in financial, crypto, and technical news. With specialized sections for each category, it provides readers with up-to-date market insights, investment trends, and technological advancements, making it a valuable resource for investors and enthusiasts in the fast-paced financial world.

Recent:

Many businesses feel stuck with outdated CRM systems due to complexity, disruption, and cost udinmwe...
NYT Strands today — my hints, answers and spangram for Wednesday, December 25 (game #297) | usagold...
NYT Connections today — my hints and answers for Wednesday, December 25 (game #563) | usagoldmines....
Quordle today – my hints and answers for Wednesday, December 25 (game #1066) | usagoldmines.com
What People Are Getting Wrong This Week: The Pope Opening the Tomb of Lucifer Stephen Johnson | usag...
This 75-inch Samsung TV Comes With a Free Soundbar and Subwoofer Combo, and a $50 Gift Card Daniel O...
iOS 18.2.1 for iPhone Now Confirmed as iOS 18.3 Beta Testing Continues Joe Rossignol | usagoldmines....
Obscure Chinese PC vendor has the world's first Qualcomm PC out of the gate: QS1 Pro runs Windows 11...
Some of the Best Headphones of 2024 Are at Their Lowest Prices Ever Daniel Oropeza | usagoldmines.co...
Grok's mobile app is here – and it might not be very careful erichs211@gmail.com (Eric Hal Schwartz)...
Who is ISoftStone? Mysterious tech firm set to become one of the biggest PC vendors in China, beatin...
Gordon Mah Ung, PCWorld editor and renowned hardware journalist, dies at 58 | usagoldmines.com
Save Time and Air Fry Your Pumpkin Pie Allie Chanthorn Reinmann | usagoldmines.com
You Should Use Transnomino to Rename and Reorganize Your Mac Files Justin Pot | usagoldmines.com
Apple Explains Why It Doesn't Plan to Create a Search Engine Joe Rossignol | usagoldmines.com
Beyoncé wins the holidays with an ultra-clever Netflix joke lance.ulanoff@futurenet.com (Lance Ulano...
Chrome could get a massive AI upgrade if this rumor is true erichs211@gmail.com (Eric Hal Schwartz) ...
My Favorite Amazon Deal of the Day: The Samsung Galaxy Buds 3 Pro Daniel Oropeza | usagoldmines.com
Seven Ways Gaining Muscle Can Benefit Your Health Beth Skwarecki | usagoldmines.com
Arc B580 surprises in content creation review: Intel's 12GB GPU is more than a match for the competi...
Best monitors 2024: Gaming, 4K, HDR, and more | usagoldmines.com
A Beginner's Guide to Buying a Weightlifting Belt Beth Skwarecki | usagoldmines.com
Here Are the Three Apple Products You're Most Likely to Unwrap This Christmas Hartley Charlton | usa...
10 things I’d never, ever do as an IT professional | usagoldmines.com
The Out-Of-Touch Adults’ Guide to Kid Culture: The Rise of Rizzmas Carols Stephen Johnson | usagoldm...
You Can Now Let Trusted Friends and Family Control Your Google Home Amanda Blum | usagoldmines.com
AirTag 2 Launching Next Year With These New Features Joe Rossignol | usagoldmines.com
$99 Apple TV Might Make a Comeback Next Year Joe Rossignol | usagoldmines.com
How to fix kinked and broken cables in no time | usagoldmines.com
The Amazon Echo Buds Are 50% Off Right Now Pradershika Sharma | usagoldmines.com
Why the Honey Extension Is Being Called the Biggest Influencer Scam of All Time David Nield | usagol...
Apple's Historically 'Bumpy Relationship' With Nvidia Detailed in Report Joe Rossignol | usagoldmine...
Popular iPhone Camera App 'Halide' Gaining Three New Features in 2025 Hartley Charlton | usagoldmine...
Adobe releases software updates to patch security issues | usagoldmines.com
Everything leaving Netflix in January 2025 rowan.davies@futurenet.com (Rowan Davies) | usagoldmines....
FTC orders Marriott and Starwood to boost cybersecurity following major incidents | usagoldmines.co...
Why The Long Kiss Goodnight is a great alt-Christmas movie Jennifer Ouellette | usagoldmines.com
These Easy Holiday Cookie Recipes Have Five Ingredients or Less Allie Chanthorn Reinmann | usagoldmi...
What 'Cardio Load' Really Means in the Fitbit App Beth Skwarecki | usagoldmines.com
US Government Defense bill waters down creation of US Cyber Force, allocates billions to "rip and re...
My first Thunderbolt 5 experience has been a huge bust | usagoldmines.com
The Best Last-Minute Christmas Gift Ideas for Under $30 Meredith Dietz | usagoldmines.com
The M4 MacBook Air is tipped to show up before new iPads and the iPhone SE 4 in 2025 | usagoldmines...
Netflix lawsuit sues VMware over virtual machine patents | usagoldmines.com
5 iPhone Camera Features to Try Out This Holiday Season Hartley Charlton | usagoldmines.com
AI development service Builder.ai exposed over 1TB of data on three million users | usagoldmines.co...
Top WordPress plugins found to have some serious security flaws, so make sure you're protected | us...
AI impersonators will wreck online security in 2025. Here’s what to watch out for | usagoldmines.co...
The Full Nerd awards: Our favorite PC hardware of 2024 | usagoldmines.com
This powerful Samsung Galaxy Book4 360 is $450 off | usagoldmines.com
Apple's First Bezel-Free iPhone Unlikely to Be Ready for 2026 Launch Tim Hardwick | usagoldmines.com
Xerox buys Lexmark for $1.5 billion to build US printer giant capable of rivaling HP waynewilliams@o...
After two decades, GIMP 3.0 has arrived with high-resolution compatibility and extensive improvement...
TV Technica 2024: Our picks for the best of TV Jennifer Ouellette | usagoldmines.com
Sega CEO confirms the company won't be making more mini retro consoles, like a potential Dreamcast M...
More malicious Python packages are on the loose, experts warn | usagoldmines.com
Max confirms more monster mayhem after renewing the DC animated series Creature Commandos for season...
Netflix's Zero Day teaser is the first time I've seen Robert De Niro starring in a TV series | usag...
Track Santa's Journey From the North Pole Using Google's Santa Tracker Tim Hardwick | usagoldmines.c...
Windows users, this is one upgrade you won’t want to miss | usagoldmines.com
Meet the platform that’s making ChatGPT obsolete | usagoldmines.com
Russian hosting firm RUVDS takes server tech to the South Pole for high-speed data tests in extreme ...
AI educators are coming to this school – and it's part of a trend erichs211@gmail.com (Eric Hal Schw...
Going Full Nerd: My favorite Gordon Ung video is a masterclass in his talents | usagoldmines.com
Quordle today – my hints and answers for Tuesday, December 24 (game #1065) | usagoldmines.com
NYT Strands today — my hints, answers and spangram for Tuesday, December 24 (game #296) | usagoldmi...
NYT Connections today — my hints and answers for Tuesday, December 24 (game #562) | usagoldmines.co...
Santa tracker 2024 live: how to follow Santa with Google or Norad josephine.watson@futurenet.com (Jo...
The Roborock Curv Is the Most Adaptable Robot Vacuum I’ve Tried So Far Amanda Blum | usagoldmines.co...
The Bose Smart Soundbar 550 Is $300 Off Right Now Daniel Oropeza | usagoldmines.com
How I Use the Skylight Calendar to Manage My Life Amanda Blum | usagoldmines.com
This new rugged Panasonic 2-in-1 tablet with 13th-gen Intel processors, 5G connectivity, and a 12-in...
X CEO Linda Yaccarino is keynoting at CES 2025, but don't expect any answers lance.ulanoff@futurenet...
Gemini’s ‘Ask About This PDF’ Feature Appears Ready for Use Tim | usagoldmines.com
Five Examples of Trash That You Can Sell for Decent Money Jeff Somers | usagoldmines.com
How to Hide the Windows 11 Taskbar (Until You Need It) Justin Pot | usagoldmines.com
The Dreo Baristamaker Is My Favorite Frother for Professional-Grade Foamed Milk Allie Chanthorn Rein...
New MacBook Air Models With M4 Chip Expected to Launch 'Earlier' Than iPhone SE 4 and iPad 11 Joe Ro...
Elon Musk’s xAI supercomputer gets 150MW power boost despite concerns over grid impact and local pow...
Report: Samsung Sets Lower Expectations for Galaxy Z Fold 7, Z Flip 7 Amid Poor Foldable Sales Tim |...
The Easiest Way to Motivate Yourself to Clean Lindsey Ellefson | usagoldmines.com
My Favorite Amazon Deal of the Day: The Amazon Fire HD 8 Tablet Daniel Oropeza | usagoldmines.com
Here Are All the Carriers That Support RCS on iPhone Jake Peterson | usagoldmines.com
How to send a personal video message from Santa using AI erichs211@gmail.com (Eric Hal Schwartz) | u...
The quest to save the world’s largest CRT TV from destruction Kyle Orland | usagoldmines.com
Reminder: Donate to win swag in our annual Charity Drive sweepstakes Kyle Orland | usagoldmines.com
The Best Way to Defog Your Windshield Beth Skwarecki | usagoldmines.com
Apple Pay Donation Campaign for World AIDS Day Raised $3 Million Joe Rossignol | usagoldmines.com
A $100bn tech company you've probably never heard of is teaming up with the world's biggest memory m...
How movies and shows end up on your streaming services: studio rights explained | usagoldmines.com
Procrastinators, There’s Still Time to Get a Discounted Pixel Device ($250 Off) Tim | usagoldmines.c...
These Games Are Leaving PS Plus Next Month Jake Peterson | usagoldmines.com
My Must-Pack Items to Sleep Well While Traveling Lindsey Ellefson | usagoldmines.com
How to Make the iOS 18 Photos App Suck Less Juli Clover | usagoldmines.com
Flu surges in Louisiana as health department barred from promoting flu shots Beth Mole | usagoldmine...
$2,100 mechanical keyboard has 800 holes, NYC skyscraper looks Scharon Harding | usagoldmines.com
The befuddling world of USB-C charging, explained | usagoldmines.com
When to Hire a Financial Advisor (and When to Invest on Your Own) Meredith Dietz | usagoldmines.com
The Apple AirPods Max Just Dropped to a New Record Low Price Daniel Oropeza | usagoldmines.com
What to Expect From iOS 19: All the Rumors So Far Joe Rossignol | usagoldmines.com

Leave a Reply